The Shasta Science-Fiction Prize Novel Contest
The Riverworld pilot came out on DVD on November 16th, 2004. As we reported in October 2004, Alliance Atlantis, in conjunction with The SciFi Channel, renewed their option on Riverworld. This means that there is hope for the series after all, but we still don't know if they will continue from the Pilot or start over from scratch. The latest update we have received is that not everyone involved is happy with the new concept so things are going to be delayed. This means that the show will not make it into this season's production schedule so we are now looking at 2006 as the earliest possible air date.
Here is the front and back of the Riverworld DVD case:
Ok, having lived through the first Riverworld TV adaptation, we didn't have very high expectations. We knew they were going to do things like have staggered resurrections. So the protagonist wakes up on a new world and discovers people who have been there for years and who know how everything works. Thus we lose one of the most fun parts of TO YOUR SCATTERED BODIES GO, the "Day of the Great Shout" where everyone who ever lived on earth suddenly wakes up naked, hairless, in a 25 year old version of their body, lying on a crowded riverbank. This of course causes many of them to completely freak out as this is not the afterlife they expected. For some reason both versions had horses even though there are no animals in the books other than fish and insects. Both versions had to make the protagonist a modern American instead of an interesting historical character like Sir Richard Francis Burton. Both versions did have Mark Twain, because most Americans have heard of him.
One thing the second version did do, was have Burton as a character, yea! But as a villian instead of the protagonist, boo! This was an interesting twist. During the novels Burton, and others, are being fed information and given help by a race of "Ethicals," to reach the tower at the end of the River. But we never really understand the motivation of their mysterious helpers. The miniseries turns this around and shows us characters being helped by "Caretakers" to stop Burton. We still don't know why rival Caretakers are trying to help or hinder Burton's quest, but now our focus is on the opposite side of the battle. Then the payoff at the end is that we finally see things from Burton's point of view. Now we're supposed to be conflicted and not know if Burton was right in his quest or not. Was our modern American hero wrong all along in trying to stop Burton (his only real movitation being that Burton stole his girl, who of course has been on the River for years before he woke up)?
As noted above, this was an interesting approach. It might have worked nicely except for one thing; in making Burton "look" like the villian, they made him a villian. It isn't a case of just misunderstanding his motivation when he's constantly giving orders like, "Burn her at the stake" and "Kill them all." No, this Burton is an asshole that no one would route for at all if he wasn't being played by Peter Wingfield (by the way, we love Peter Wingfield, but they might as well have cast Mos Def if they weren't even going to try and find someone who looked anything at all like Burton).
Having said all that, we're still hoping for a TV series. Maybe with some practice the writers will figure out how to best utilize this amazing world Farmer created.
2010
A short review containing spoilers